Our Money is Complicated, but Making a Difference is Not

Friends,

In an effort to be transparent without drowning you with details, I am writing an article each week about one esoteric or confusing detail about our Church’s money situation, and this week’s topic is all the different pots of money we have and how we can simultaneously be fairly well off in one area and desperately behind in others.

I feel like this is turning into one of Megan Costilow’s “Newcomer Survival Guides,” which you can find on her blog, “Becoming Episcopalian.” You may come across these terms and have no idea what they mean; treat this as your translation guide.

Rector’s Discretionary Fund: Despite its name, I cannot spend this money at my discretion. Per Church law, this fund must be used to help people in the community. Very specifically, I use it to help pay for people’s rent or utilities. I help in a big way (about $1000), but only one time. This fund is not part of our operating budget; it's funded by what you put in the plate on the first Sunday of the month, and I choose to put all honoraria from weddings and funerals into this fund rather than keep them.

The Diocese: Some people think that the Diocese gives us money, but it goes the other way! The Diocese provides us with much of the infrastructure we need to exist. When everything is going smoothly, it is easy to take them for granted. The couple of times the feces hit the fan in my ministry, the Diocese has been invaluable. We are obligated to give the Diocese 10% of our operating budget based on a three-year average.

Outreach: You may think it is bad that we don't have an outreach line item in our operating budget, but this protects the outreach budget, since the vestry doesn't have the authority to cut this separate budget.  Historically, their budget is funded by direct gifts, the craft fair, and, recently, the pumpkin patch.

Capital Expenses: A capital expense is an improvement to the physical plant, rather than a regular expense or maintenance. For example, replacing all the drinking fountains with identical ones would not be a capital expense. If we replaced them with the kind that also fills your bottle, then it would be, because it would be an improvement. This differentiation is very important for the next two entries on this list.

Creating Resources In Sacred Places (CRISP): I came up with this acronym, and I think it’s pretty great. The mission of the committee is straightforward, but how they are funded is complicated. They help steer and execute capital expenseprojects in the Church. They are primarily funded by the revenue we receive from the rent from the cell phone towers in the steeple. For tax reasons, those funds can only be used on capital expenses. They cannot go to fund the operations of the Church.

The Endowment: Our endowment has grown significantly in recent years due to the generosity of many people and to being invested very wisely. We are bound to spend the money according to the rules that the original givers established. These rules clearly stipulate that the endowment can only be used for capital expenses and to start new ministries. We can spend up to the principal, which is what was put into it. Let’s say we had a million dollars in the endowment; that means a million dollars is invested, but we aren’t necessarily able to spend all of it. While it is sometimes frustrating, it is very smart. Large unrestricted endowments can often kill churches. There are Churches completely funded by endowments with no one in the pews. It turns out that if you don’t have to try to survive, you often stop trying.

OPERATING BUDGET!!!!!!

Everything before this point has nothing to do with the Church's daily function. It has nothing to do with keeping the lights on, paying salaries, paying for an absurd amount of paper towels (where do they all go?), and just making things happen. All of this is funded by direct gifts from our community. If we can increase the operating budget, we can do more ministry, and that's what the Stewardship Season is all about. The operating budget is divided into two big sections: pledge and plate. They can both be spent on anything, but why they are divided is important. The remaining items on this list are all about the operating budget.

Pledge: Many churches call Stewardship Season a “Pledge Campaign,” which might be more straightforward now that I think about it. A pledge isn’t a check right now, but a plan for your giving for the next year. My wife and I spoke and decided how much we could give to St. Luke’s in 2027, and we filled out the online form (twice by mistake, sorry, Rachel). When we talk about the Year-to-Date pledge income, we mean the pledges people made this year that have been fulfilled. Some people give their whole pledge in January, others in December, and others write a check every week. Any of these are fine, but we try to keep an eye on where we are throughout the year so we can have enough cash flow to pay bills. We will be sending out statements more often so we can catch mistakes that will inevitably happen. Look out for those and let us know if something doesn’t look right!

Tithe: This one deserves to be noted but does not neatly fit into how I am laying this out. Some Churches use “tithe” in the same way we use “pledge”. We talk about tithing too, but it is different. The way we talk about tithing is the biblical definition: ten percent of your income. This is the first Church that I’ve served in where multiple people tithe. Up until this year, I counted myself as one of them. However, our financial situation changed, and honestly, we kind of are, and kind of aren't, depending on how you look at it. We are more generous than ever, because we are excited about what’s happening at St. Luke’s. Tom Hargrove has a great testimonial about tithing. I encourage you to talk to him if you want to learn more.

Plate: Let’s say you’re new to the Church and just started giving, or you simply forgot to fill out a pledge form; then your gift goes in this part of the operating income. This money is spent the same way as the pledge income, which is on the operating expenses of the Church, but it isn’t fulfilling anyone’s pledge. If we can track your gift, we will, you will get a letter from the Church that you can use on your taxes. If you just throw in cash, then your gift is still greatly appreciated, but we cannot necessarily track it!

 

There are many reasons to be generous to St. Luke’s, and many reasons to be cynical about Churches wanting your money. Jesus preached against people flaunting money to be better perceived in their religious communities. Jesus also always quickly pointed out that our trust should be in God more than in our own wealth and resources. Some give simply because it makes them feel good. Others give to feel less bound to the lure of wealth. I used to tithe the income I earned from the Church, so I would feel less guilty and feel that I was giving enough. Now I give because I genuinely want to see what we can do if our staff ever feels full. We’ll work for God’s kingdom. Sometimes we’ll get it right; other times we’ll miss the mark, but we’ll always try. I give not because I know we’ll succeed in measurable ways, but just because I am curious what we can do with this place.

If I can ever take the mystery out of the business of Church and help you discern how you can be generous with your time, talent, and treasure, just let me know.

Blessings,

Nick

Pledging is how you make a difference. Share your giving plans for 2027 by clicking this link.